Ive alway thought that Eva Levante was the gardener and for a bit i was thinking maybe the drifter as the winnower but it never fit right until i realized its Osiris… i think him and eva are brother and sister and both members of the eldritch race. The last collapse created the awoken which are the same dynamic siblings. Both born of light and dark. If you look into Osiris background it says he was a creation of the golden age. And was resurrected by a faulty ghost. So Im wondering. Was humanity responsible for creating both the gardener and winnower? Are we the race that created the witness also?….. and Clovis knows more than we think about all of this.