{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
9/4/2015 2:02:33 PM
33
Halo: bullets and plasma
Star Wars: lasers and magic
Star Wars wins
English
-
[quote]Halo, plasma orbital death Rays and general planet--blam!-ing-over WMDs[/quote] Plus Master Chief.
-
We have jango and bobba for him
-
Master Chief vs an entire ruthless army, and Master Chief won. I'm pretty sure master Chief would win. Plus, Boba fell into the Sarlacc pit like what, 5 times?
-
And made it out 5 times
-
Still, did he have a street grudge with it? Why did he keep coming back?
-
Just your average, shallow outlaw looking for stupid difficult life goals
-
Lol :D I guess toilet-paper-head man needed some time to figure out how to be a parent, so he helped Boba recover when he fell in the first time. Oh toilet-paper-head man, you're the best.
-
Halo, plasma orbital death Rays and general planet--blam!-ing-over WMDs
-
Halo: halo rings
-
*cough*Spartan laser*cough *
-
Fair point. That things is kinda the bomb
-
Halo wins actually [spoiler]infinite respawns at checkpoint[/spoiler]
-
-
Someone doesn't know Halo's extended lore...
-
Someone doesn't know Star Wars extended lore. Sith eat flood for breakfast and poop them out as dinosaur slaves
-
No the flood would eat the sith
-
Dino-shrooms shall ingulf the fictiondom
-
Edited by BobRonJJ: 9/6/2015 4:15:00 AMHalo rings
-
How so when the force doesn't affect extra galactic life? In an all out war between both galaxies Halo wins. Production time: takes the empire 1 year to fully build a Death Star. The forerunners can strip mine an earth size planet and use the materials to create 1 Halo ring every 9 days. Ship building: Star Wars takes several months to construct 2 star destroyer. Forerunners can grow (yes grow) a dreadnought class vessel (one of the smallest being the Dicdacts ship the mantles approach) larger then the Death Star in just a couple of days. Single fighters: takes the empire approximately two months to build a squadron of Tie fighters. The Forerunners can create single attack vessels in minutes literally by the thousands. (Even in small groups these have enough firepower to vaporise cities and upturn continents) Droid fighters: Star Wars can produce droid armies in a short space of time around 5,000 units per day per factory. The forerunners have a sentinel class whose shields and weapons double with each with each sentinel that combines to the group. A squad of 50 (each around 4ft long and 2 ft high) can one shot a covenant flagship with full shields from stem to stern. These can be created at rate of 1 every 6 seconds. Constraint fields: a technology based version of the force. Promethean's and Armigers full composed of hard light and having sophisticated A.I programming they can also do short slipspace jumps to appear behind enemies/obstacles created in the thousands. Now add ancient humanity and the san'shyum whom were at the same technological level as the Forerunners except in slipsace engineering and you now have 3 highly advanced races creating trillions of units per month (if not weeks) with no loss of a single life as the forerunners humans and other species retreat to shield worlds contained in slipspace controlling a vast automated army of hard light and death.
-
That force thing is hogwash. Both galaxies each with the same rules. Your Star Wars numbers are way off. Just play a Star Wars game like rogue squadron and you know the empire alone daily created thousands of ships not to mention private or planetary productions. Trillions of units? First of all many of the armies you speak of are not at that strength in the games and not relevant to this. Second ships in star wars are on average much larger than topical halo aircraft making your firepower display somewhat underwhelming. To be honest though im more of a halo 1,2,3 player so I might not be giving prometheans enough credit.
-
Well the topic was the whole of Halo vs Star Wars didn't realise it's a game only thing. As for the force thing that's cherry picking it's clearly shown and was canon and seeing as no contradicting canon has been put in place of it it still stands. Seeing as the Forerunners alone had 3 million worlds trillion/s is not a far off number especially after adding in around 663 sheiks worlds with production plants numerous space stations both in and outside of slipspace and then add in all of humanities and the san'shyum sits not a hard number to reach. Meh neither Promethean's or Armigers (as far as is currently known) are to difficult to destroy but it's their sheer numbers that overwhelm and destroy the enemy. The Halo universe is quiet barebones until Hlao4 and the expanded universe of Star Wars gets to use it so does halo.
-
The force most definitely is included. In the very first movie it is stated to surround all things and bind them together which is part of their fiction not location. As far as numbers go, the Star Wars universe has over a hundred billion "star systems" most of which include planets that are quite advanced and capable of space flight. If you include the fact that a Sith is capable of popping a star's cherry with a concentrated wink, and mandolorians had armor that was impervious to lightsabers (so everything in halo) I think Star Wars has more than a fighting chance
-
Indeed it does but as for the force it still doesn't work you are still cherry picking your lines the argument is both universes films games all canon vs the other and EU Star Wars canon the force doesn't affect extra galactic life. As much as it seems you are debating with me you are instead debating with Star Wars own canon. As I've said while the limits are unknown it may be an individual thing or they may be to incapacitate/kill multiple targets constraints fields are a technology based version of the force and it works regardless of Galaxy of origin. I'm not saying Halo would curb stomp Star Wars without a fight but I do see it as Halo has a much better chance of winning at a much lower cost to lives of soldiers. Star Wars has clones fine fair enough but they still take months to mature,train etc Halo can create millions of Knights Armigers and sentinels in hours. As for Star Wars own droid force in comparison to a knight even a heavy battle droid is an unfair match. Tech for tech. Knight:comprised of hard light+ shields use a variety of hard light weapons mainly the light rifle firing compressed super dense beams of light that deconstruct those hit by it at an atomic scale. Uses mini slipspace portals to gain an advantage take cover and reorganise the group. Heavy battle droid: tough armour no shields uses built in laser guns that deal medium damage to a none organic slow to move and movie wise not particularly clever. Trooper wise Halo would have an issue especially with the impervious armour but as I said it's not an individual knight that's the issue its the sheer numbers they attack in.
-
What canon are you going on about? I have never heard this force doesn't count argument. Also I just explained that combining the standing armies of the star wars universe along with the flash cloning of the empire (insta-meh soldiers) would give Star Wars the numbers advantage.
-
For some one rooting for Star Wars you seem to be missing some key lore points. Extra galactic life meaning life from outside of the Galaxy isn't directly affected by the force if you've never read the Yuzan Vong story arch you should. Being from another galaxy they are on a different 'frequency' to those of the Star Wars universe (I.e life in their Galaxy wasn't created nor does it contains midiclorians they basically exist outside of the force) Hence why force abilities have no direct effect force push/pull lighting choke hell even battle meditation doesn't work with them. The only way to hurt them via the force was to use the force to pick up say a boulder and squash them with it. Basically making the Jedi and Soth nothing more then excellent saber fighters. Which is still true Except knights have plasma swords which are basically the same thing. As for the clones true the process got refined and became quicker but nowhere near insta clones they still took weeks to mature while Knights and other forerunner armies are grown overnight.
