ITT: people think opinions are objective, that goes for you too OP. In my Opinion it would be Witcher 3, Fallout 4 hasn't come out so i can't judge (super hyped for it tho), MGS V has an "ok" story with a veeeeery boring open world and a good portion of repetitiveness (wouldn't care if it changed the area with every mission but it doesn't). Tbh i find Mad Max very fun (yet still has a lot of repetitive scenarios) so i may throw a bone for it. I don't consider Exclusives as GOTY unless they won that title for their respective console, so i expect Bloodmeme and Halo 5: kekdians to win in their respective consoles(leaning over Gears of War Ultimate edition to win for the X1 tho). I'll have to wait until Super Mario Maker comes out to see if it's good enough to win GOTY for Wii U. As for the big(kek) websites decisions, the only contenders they consider worthy are MGSV, Fallout 4 and Witcher 3. Hopefully all of you start controlling your triggers and learn that everyone has different tastes.