I would love to have the emotes free. But there is no place saying we deserve them for free. And I would rather have it be an optional buying of cosmetic items and free dlcs than having to buy all the dlcs. If I want I can get all the DLCs fie year 2 for nothing or I can spend the same amount I did last year and get the DLCs and emotes. Seems fair on either side. Bungie does still need to make money