I don't care if it would net me $4. That's $4 more than I had before instead of a broken piece of plastic. Say what you will about the game, but snapping it in half instead of turning it in is fiscally irresponsible. Keep in mind, someone paid $60 for the thing. To purposefully destroy it is dumb. That's coming from someone that's invested approximately $500 in new controllers because of stupidity. The pot is calling the kettle black, here.