Why so little love for Reach? As good as all three numerical Halos were under Bungie's watch, Reach was so much better. Visually, I would even argue it's on par with Destiny. Gameplay was better than any previous Halo. The storytelling and character development were top notch. The music dragged the overall audio experience down a bit, but the effects were so good that music mattered very little. And then there was Firefight... As much as I love those core Halo games by Bungie, I can't choose them over Reach... As for other Bungie titles, I haven't played enough of them to be able to fairly judge them. Marathon (what I played of it, anyways) was pretty good, and my small dose of Oni was certainly enjoyable, but I just don't have enough experience with these titles to definitively say they were or weren't better than any Halo. Destiny, while very good, is just not as fulfilling as any Halo title on Bungie's resumé. TL;DR I think Reach needs some more love here as it is easily the most complete Bungie game to date IMHO.