Bungie. Oh and yes you are correct PVP is killing the game and has been for a long time. All the poor efforts at weapons balance has trashed primary weapons like no one could have dreamed yet they stay at it over and over. We are trashing subclasses, supers, nades the list is endless. Every kid on the planet who dies from anything in the crucible comes and cries out. Then all his little buddies join in. Then something else is trashed. We have nothing worth a damn left but it still goes on every single day the entire forum is swamped with the posts. Again though Bungie is also trashing the game. PVP had not a damn thing to do with time gating, making all old content useless, taking away elemental primaries, The joke of a light system. All of that falls back on bungie.