In my opinion the paleocontact auto is better then both yes it has a little slower rate of fire but over better stats and the roof is not that much of a difference Rof=88 Impact=8 Range=44 Stability=54 can be more with right roll Reload=68 Magazine=57 can be more with field scout So jn my opinion I take more impact and range for a little less Rof and it can hold its own against the doctrine just opinion though as everyone has there preferred gun