{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
Edited by Koldraxon:
3/30/2016 11:21:49 AM
25
Sovereign, Mantle's Approach, Harbinger, Hunhow, Warden Eternal, (maybe) Ur-Didact, Clem, Inaros (Warframe), a Promethean Knight, a Forerunner Guardian...
[spoiler]
Evidence: Sovereign is a Reaper. The Mantle's Approach is vast, and durable, and should be able to sustain the damage, Harbinger is also a Reaper, Hunhow is a Sentient Destroyer of Worlds, and can adapt to damage like his drones. He can manipulate technology and turn it against it's wielder (see: Fall of the Orokin Empire), Warden Eternal due to his spare bodies, Ur-Didact -might- be able to survive a hit?, Clem can be cloned again, Inaros is a Warframe with (if set up correctly) a lot of heatlh and could survive the damage theoretically speaking and is a Warframe (which can just be rebuilt if destroyed), a Promethean Knight's Watcher will resurrect the Knight, a Forerunner Guardian can EMP the Death Star, forcing the Empire to 'reload' the weapon. Additional evidence can be researched. You haven't.
Not all mentioned are valid candidates.[/spoiler]
English
-
Sebastian shaw from x-men
-
Warden Eternal doesn't count, because the one hit is dead.
-
Point is valid due to his spare bodies being destructible, but to destroy -all- of him? He's the [i]Keeper of the Domain. [/i]That'd probably mean he is a part of it, if he is to protect it the way he does.
-
It falls under the same issue as Clem or Promrthians. The entity still dies from the hit, despite potentially coming back.
-
No he is not killed. He is a AI so he can exist on multiple body's at once.
-
Yes, but the rest aren't hit at all. The unit hit is gone. So I'd rack it as a loss.
-
The thread asks who can survive. He survived.
-
So would then, say, the Chosen Undead or a Warframe
-
Can they survive without a body?
-
Both can, yes.
-
Can I have a citation?
-
So in the end, it's still a loss. So be it. Let's put a Halo Ring in it's way. Or the Ark. Or Requiem itself.
-
A Halo ring is too fragile. The Ark would need insane shielding. Requiem definitely would have shielding, but would it be enough?
-
Halos have shields they could activate, so would the Ark I would imagine. It's up in the air how strong they are though.
-
A Halo is fragile, you're correct there, but where's the Death Star hitting exactly? The Ark is gigantic, the one we saw in Halo 3 is it's Lesser, according to what I know. Requiem surely has enough hull strength to refract some of the damage before taking a scar on it's outermost shell, along with the shields. It's a Warrior-Servant world after all.
-
[quote]A Halo is fragile, you're correct there, but where's the Death Star hitting exactly? ------- It has shields that I could activate. But idk how strong they are. ------- The Ark is gigantic, the one we saw in Halo 3 is it's Lesser, according to what I know. Requiem surely has enough hull strength to refract some of the damage before taking a scar on it's outermost shell, along with the shields. It's a Warrior-Servant world after all.[/quote] ------ Not without shields.
-
[quote]Sovereign, Mantle's Approach, Harbinger, Hunhow, Warden Eternal, (maybe) Ur-Didact, Clem, Inaros (Warframe), a Promethean Knight, a Forerunner Guardian... [spoiler] Evidence: Sovereign is a Reaper. ------ This protects it how? ------ The Mantle's Approach is vast, ------ Not as vast as a planet. ------ and durable, and should be able to sustain the damage, ------ We don't know that. ------ Harbinger is also a Reaper, ------ So? ------ Hunhow is a Sentient Destroyer of Worlds, and can adapt to damage like his drones. He can manipulate technology and turn it against it's wielder (see: Fall of the Orokin Empire), ------ How does this make him durable enough to survive 53 quadrillion megatons? ------ Warden Eternal due to his spare bodies, Ur-Didact -might- be able to survive a hit?, ------ No, no way in hell. ------ Clem can be cloned again, ------ Still counts as death. ------ Inaros is a Warframe with (if set up correctly) a lot of heatlh and could survive the damage theoretically speaking and is a Warframe (which can just be rebuilt if destroyed), ------ Gameplay is not allowed as proof. ------ a Promethean Knight's Watcher will resurrect the Knight, ------ Still counts as death. ------ a Forerunner Guardian can EMP the Death Star, forcing the Empire to 'reload' the weapon. ------ It can't avoid the Death Stars blast, it actually has to survive being hit. ------ Additional evidence can be researched. You haven't.[/spoiler][/quote] ------ You didn't read the rules.
-
Edited: Not all mentioned are valid candidates. Still, if you're not willing to provide the intel, then why should I?
-
Edited by Edcub One: 3/30/2016 4:24:08 PMReapers have been destroyed by mass effect ship weapons. There is no proof Mantles Approach could survive. The Didact was hurt by a grenade and a Promethean is hurt by small arms. Gameplay is also not proof for a Warframe surviving.
-
At least they were candidates. [spoiler]0: That was concentrated fire and the Reapers were moving; depends on the type of Reaper. 1: The Mantle's Approach was infiltrated and 117 disabled it's point defense guns, allowing the UNSC to throw enough at it to cut it's shields out. 2: That was a poor move by 343I, the grenade simply didn't have room to explode, and that was a Pulse Grenade. 3: Those were COMPOSED Prometheans, designed to fight the Flood. Obviously gameplay has dumbed down their effectiveness and Halo 4 had not shown their prowess off well. 4: Hunhow clearly states "Sever their heads, yet they rise again..." Hunhow's power has not yet been determined, except that he let himself play dead for the Tenno to eradicate the Orokin. 5: DEATH STAR, MEET BALOR (Formorian)! ...? [/spoiler]
-
Edited by Edcub One: 3/31/2016 9:59:57 PM[quote]At least they were candidates. [spoiler]0: That was concentrated fire and the Reapers were moving; depends on the type of Reaper. ------- No, Reapers die to kiloton level fire power. The Death Star laser generates 53 quadrillion megatons of energy. ------- 1: The Mantle's Approach was infiltrated and 117 disabled it's point defense guns, allowing the UNSC to throw enough at it to cut it's shields out. ------- Ok, this doesn't proof it could survive. ------- 2: That was a poor move by 343I, the grenade simply didn't have room to explode, and that was a Pulse Grenade. ------- What do you mean it didn't have space? A Pulse grenade can vaporize Hunters, so being hurt by it is not a low showing. ------- 3: Those were COMPOSED Prometheans, designed to fight the Flood. Obviously gameplay has dumbed down their effectiveness and Halo 4 had not shown their prowess off well. ------- Designed by a mad man. They are shown time and time again to be on a similar level to the UNSC and Covenant. They are nothing to the true Forerunner military. ------- 4: Hunhow clearly states "Sever their heads, yet they rise again..." Hunhow's power has not yet been determined, except that he let himself play dead for the Tenno to eradicate the Orokin. ------- Surviving decapitation is not the same as surviving vaporization. ------- 5: DEATH STAR, MEET BALOR (Formorian)! ...? [/spoiler][/quote] ------- What do you mean?
-
What was in the spoiler was a second attempt at providing information.
-
Read what I said in the spoiler. Also I was referring to the 5th point.
-
Worse than that he's outright wrong about Sovereign and Harbinger. Sure, they could dodge the shot, but they are absolutely, positively -blam!-ED if they get hit. Kinetic Barriers ain't got shit against an energy weapon, let alone the Death Star.
-
Not all of them are valid candidates, obviously.
