I played Dark souls 1 and Dark souls 3 before Ds2:SotFS, and even with that ds2 is my favorite. Its challenging but never really gets really frustrating like the others, the game performs beautifully, and I love the freedom offered by things like the soul vessels.
I also like how you get some choices on where to go first at some points, mainly in the beginning and at the memory sequence part.
-
I thought it was pretty darn great, still liked DS1 over it, I found the reliance on battling multiple attackers at once didn't fit the Souls style very well. The PvP is debatably the best in the series imo