It makes sense, no? Dwe.., I mean year 1 players who have claymore, get the broadsword early for suffering after year 1 pvp too much. And hu..., I mean players who don't have claymore can get an exclusive emblem for getting their weapon through grinding and honourable feets of true power. This would make both sides happy, besides you can't please everyone by giving making a few of them get it without any year 2 sweat, right? I am free to people to suggest any alternative to that idea, but really players who hate awful year 1 pvp, don't derserve to be slapped in the face.