A) You're talking about people leaving and rejoining. I agree, no special ammo refill for those. But that's a non-sequitur. What I'm taking about is someone leaving and a new player joining that match in their place. Those players didn't choose the "Screw Me Over" game mode from the playlist so they should not be punished. B) Moreover, what you're taking about only affects people playing against the top 1%, perhaps 1-2% of all players. What I'm taking about affects 100% of the players. Regardless, there's a super easy fix that would also fix a MAJOR issue with people being unfairly punished when they're disconnected because of Bungie's servers... If a player leaves a match, Bungie can ping the player's ISP (not the player's IP). If the ping fails, the player was clearly disconnected unintentionally (probably an issue w/ Bungie's servers) and the player should not be punished. If the ping succeeds, the issue is on the player's end (disconnected, quit, etc.) and the player should be punished with a warning if it's a comp or Trials match and no special ammo if they rejoin an in-progress match.

That does sound like a good idea, and it sucks when you get disconnected and have to rejoin with no special too Yeah if they figure out a way to see if its a legit disconnect then its ok I suppose