Its probably a bad idea for a recruiter to complain in the LFC forum about the recruitment process... but you asked, so I'm gonna be brutally honest. Have you bothered to message those ppl to ask why they left? When you invite someone, do you tell them what time zone your members are in, or do you take the "everyone is welcome" approach & have no idea whether ppl are even on at the same time? Your clan page says "weekly events & challenges", do you actually do those, or is it just a marketing scheme? Are you being honest that you're probably a very casual and/or returning player ? All 3 of your characters are under 1990 light level, which is kind of a red flag since most ppl know there's free 2020 armor in the Rite of Nine Sanctuary. Its literally the first thing I tell new players, whether they join my clan or not, just open the chest & level up quick without even firing a weapon. I'm not trying to single you out here, LOTS of recruitment posts all have the same spiel "join now, we do it all, endgame, Day 1" etc etc... then you check the clan roster & no one has more than 5 raid clears, how they gonna teach? Yea, some ppl just hop in & out of clans like frogs, but lots of the recruiters are promising all kinds of stuff they'll never deliver, all cuz they're focused on numbers, instead of who's a good fit or not. The "faithful" thing goes both ways.