Halo 4 had the potential to do better, but instead they chose not to fix the problems that were there in Reach while adding to the list... and fixing things that weren't broken(Forge) Campaign: H4(and not by much. I would have liked Reach more if it didn't throw the existing storyline out a window/as a standalone game outside the Halo series) Multiplayer: Reach Forge/custom games: Reach Player Customization: Reach Could contribute to the walls of text, but won't since I've got class in the morning. For now, I'll just say that Halo 4 didn't leave enough unanswered questions- they started and ended everything in a span of 8 hours. The problem is it feels like the story is over- the main villain seems dead, Cortana broke(A key driving force in the series was Cortana/chief's relationship, which is now forced to come to a close), and the only problem left are those storm covies but weren't they killed off in Spartan Ops(sorry if thats wrong, I lent a cousin the game 2 months ago and have yet to get it back)? Edit: Darn it, contributed to the wall of texts >_<