This thread is inspired by another: view original post
In light of recent discussions regarding the ethnicity of the Human Torch, from Marvel Comics' [i]Fantastic Four[/i], I was curious as to what people would think of a black actor being cast as Superman.
Now before I say anything else, I want to state that I have absolutely no problem with black characters or actors, as I can see this thread quickly turning into a "you're racist" flame war. Thus, I must remind participants to keep this discussion cordial.
Now regarding a black Superman, allow me to set the conditions of the vote. We are not using comic book examples of a black Superman, as what looks good in a comic can look absolutely silly in a live action film (Batman's costume is an excellent example of this). Furthermore, alterations to Superman's costume will not be considered, as a change in palette can radically influence how a black Superman might look. Therefore, let's assume that the costume in question is the Man of Steel costume.
Finally, I must once again ask participants to keep the discussion civil and cordial; no insults, allegations of racism, sexism, etc.
Thank you for your time.
-
I think the Human Torch and Superman are different in the sense that one has been culturally ingrained into our society and the other has not. The Human Torch is malleable in the fact that no one really knows who he is outside of comic lore, at least in comparison to the A-listers. Changing the ethnicity of Superman is different because Superman is so culturally stapled that it would just be an insult to the character.