I am one of these people as well. I definitely remember being a Legendary / Mythic member before but due to not commenting a few years back it went down to heroic but that was linked to my previous gamertag. Feeling really let down. Can see I've been here 7 years (This account alone) by highlighting my name but not a thing unlocked for me. A ok fix would've been deduced by how many years you've been here too to unlock things in the end. Been here since ONI, wish someone would look into for us much as we did spreading good word about games