Never heard the "cruicible weapons only" idea, sounds gross. Arnt the gear stats already nerfed to a certain extent between PVE and the PVP though? Honestly, the only reasonable option I've come across to make atleast most people happy in this community to balance PVP and make rewards for PVE worth it so far, is to seperate the weapon stats between the two gameplay styles. Shax can change the rules of the Cruicible anytime he wants, he owns it after all :p.