Graphics is comparing apples and oranges, Borderlands has a cell-shading style Rating? Wtf does that mean? Claptrap is a memorable character. Give me ONE memorable character from this game (hint, none of them are) This is a repeat of your first one so it already doesn't count, but whether or not you personally prefer one art style over another is not evidence of one being superior or not. Borderlands has FAR superior weapons both in power and variety.